Your thoughts?
Edit:Sorry for the typo in the title.
Spot on.
Decent
Meh
Terrible
Your thoughts?
Edit:Sorry for the typo in the title.
I think he was reasonable, but the movies dragged him down. I'd have liked to see Garfield as the MCU Spider-Man, but I'm glad those movies aren't canon anymore
Feel he was much too old at the time to be playing a high schooler. I think he would have been better suited for a college aged Peter Parker.
I don't hate Garfield, but those movies were bad. And his Peter was bad.
Decent, but not spot on. I'll definitely he say he was a much better adaptation of 616 Peter than either Tobey or (especially) Holland. Plus he was also the best actor of the three.
"Anyone can win a fight when the odds are easy! It's when the going's tough - when there seems to be no chance - that's when it counts!" - Spider-Man
I like Garfield as an actor, but disliked his Peter Parker. Holland is meh for me. Maguire was decent. None were spot on.
Here is how I rank the Peter’s. 1: Holland. 2: Maguire. 3: Garfield. Although I thought the first two Maguire’s were the best of the lot (especially the second with Molina as Otto). I thought the third one sucked ( a hyperactive Maguire and an atrocious James Franco as Harry were why) which is why I ranked them the way I did. Garfield was the worst of the Peter’s. Without Emma Stone as Gwen the films would have been as bad as TASM 3 or Batman & Robin ( Clooney is still the worst Batman).
Last edited by NC_Yankee; 04-17-2021 at 02:07 PM.
Garfield alternated between moody loner and too-cool-for-school, with a few touches of creepy stalked mixed in.
None of those elements make for a good Spider-man.
He's easily the worst of the bunch.
I liked his performance in the first movie. I saw it as a pride before the fall story and I thought it worked. I just saw the Lizard as the movie's weak point. He felt out of place in the movie to me. Although I liked Ifans's performance and the tie-in videogame did something good with Connors.
Confuzzled made a good point about him being better in College which I agree.
I forgot about the stalking. Maybe nix that or have it blow up in his face?