Your favorite version of Justice Society of America

[caj]

With 64 people having now voted,

* JSA = 32 votes
* Bronze Age = 13 votes
* All Star Squadron = 7 votes
* Robinson's The Golden Age = 3 votes
* Golden Age (All Star Comics) = 2 votes
* Infinity Inc. = 2 votes
* Silver Age = 2 votes

All other options currently have either 1 or no votes at present.

Thanks for updating the votes. The top 3 are probably not going to change but I'm glad some of the others are getting a few votes.

[MajorHoy]

With 66 votes,

* JSA = 33 votes
* Bronze Age = 13 votes
* All Star Squadron = 8 votes
* Robinson's The Golden Age = 3 votes
* Golden Age (All Star Comics) = 2 votes
* Infinity Inc. = 2 votes
* Silver Age = 2 votes

All other options still currently have either 1 or no votes at present.

[MajorHoy]

With 69 votes now,

* JSA = 34 votes
* Bronze Age = 13 votes
* All Star Squadron = 8 votes
* Robinson's The Golden Age = 3 votes
* Golden Age (All Star Comics) = 3 votes
* Infinity Inc. = 2 votes
* Silver Age = 2 votes
* Justice Society of America (2007-2011 run) = 2 votes

All other options still currently have either 1 or no votes at present.

[MajorHoy]

With 71 votes now,

* JSA = 35 votes (+1)
* Bronze Age = 13 votes
* All Star Squadron = 9 votes (+1)
* Robinson's The Golden Age = 3 votes
* Golden Age (All Star Comics) = 3 votes
* Infinity Inc. = 2 votes
* Silver Age = 2 votes
* Justice Society of America (2007-2011 run) = 2 votes

All other options still currently have either 1 or no votes at present.

[The Darknight Detective]

Fairly close between pre- and post-COIE versions of the JSA in regard to the vote tally, which is pretty remarkable since the former has been history for almost forty years now.

I selected the Bronze Age as a stand-in for the multiverse JSA, FWIW.

[WonderScott]

Mine hasn’t occurred… yet.

[MajorHoy]

With 73 votes now,

* JSA (1999-2006) = 35 votes
* Bronze Age = 14 votes
* All Star Squadron = 9 votes
* Robinson's The Golden Age = 3 votes
* Golden Age (All Star Comics <1940-1951>) = 3 votes
* Infinity Inc. = 3 votes
* Silver Age = 2 votes
* Justice Society of America (2007-2011 run) = 2 votes

All other options still currently have either 1 or no votes at present.

[caj]

What are your feelings as to how COIE affected the Justice Society of America?

Were the creators of COIE fair to JSA? Between COIE and Zero Hour, was JSA disrespected?

How have 21st Century writers fixed some issues, if any?

[MajorHoy]

What are your feelings as to how COIE affected the Justice Society of America?

Were the creators of COIE fair to JSA? Between COIE and Zero Hour, was JSA disrespected?

How have 21st Century writers fixed some issues, if any?

I question the bit about "Were the creators of COIE fair to JSA?" Do you mean Marv Wolfman (writer) and George Pérez (artist)?
How many of the decisions regarding the JSA and CoIE were made by them vs. dictated by editors and other higher ups?
I know Roy Thomas had been uncertain about things regarding certain heroes and how CoIE would wind up affecting them in the long run, but I don't think what Marv Wolfman was writing was the cause of that.

[caj]

I question the bit about "Were the creators of COIE fair to JSA?" Do you mean Marv Wolfman (writer) and George Pérez (artist)?
How many of the decisions regarding the JSA and CoIE were made by them vs. dictated by editors and other higher ups?
I know Roy Thomas had been uncertain about things regarding certain heroes and how CoIE would wind up affecting them in the long run, but I don't think what Marv Wolfman was writing was the cause of that.

By creators, I'm including editors. Anyone involved with the direction of COIE in how they handled Earth 1 and 2 merging into one Earth and how to handle JSA characters.

[MajorHoy]

With 76 votes,

* JSA (1999-2006) = 36 votes (+1)
* Bronze Age = 15 votes (+1)
* All Star Squadron = 10 votes (+1)
* Robinson's The Golden Age = 3 votes
* Golden Age (All Star Comics <1940-1951>) = 3 votes
* Infinity Inc. = 3 votes
* Silver Age = 2 votes
* Justice Society of America (2007-2011 run) = 2 votes

All other options still currently have either 1 or no votes at present.

[caj]

Mine hasn’t occurred… yet.

I'd be curious as to what you would want in a Justice Society book? What would you like that none of the others haven't offered.