Uncanny X-men 19 [LGY 641] review *spoilers*

[Glio]

In DoX, they were being written like they were together and that ambiguity never really got resolved.



they had the Utopians IIRC

Yes, the Utopians joined him. Karma, Boom Boom and a lot of people that I do not remember or care about.

[TheDeadSpace]

Why Scott asked about Jean and not about Emma in the annual.

Ah, okay. Well, wouldn't it have been more weird and messed up if he told kid Cable that he needed to see Jean and Emma? Did he honestly need to list everyone he cared about? Considering she was dead for so long and was finally back, it makes sense Jean would be the priority. I don't understand how this blew up.

[Glio]

Ah, okay. Well, wouldn't it have been more weird and messed up if he told kid Cable that he needed to see Jean and Emma? Did he honestly need to list everyone he cared about? Considering she was dead for so long and was finally back, it makes sense Jean would be the priority. I don't understand how this blew up.

I wish Scott had asked if the Mets had won, so we would not be discussing this.

[ExodusCloak]

Emma runs to him at the cafe, which was AFTER being on lockdown by WiFi. It’s clearly shown that in the comics...

No Emma makes him go to the cafe. It's not a coincidence. What's shown in the comics is that he is not allowed to make a public appearance as Cyclops he is allowed to go to pubs as long as he's low key. He was also psychically coerced to be there. I'm pretty sure they'll reveal what and when in the later issues.

[TheDeadSpace]

I wish Scott had asked if the Mets had won, so we would not be discussing this.

Anything else would have been better.

[spirit2011]

No Emma makes him go to the cafe. It's not a coincidence. What's shown in the comics is that he is not allowed to make a public appearance as Cyclops he is allowed to go to pubs as long as he's low key. He was also psychically coerced to be there.

he has been going out for some time. on x-men #11 he says that he is going to the cafe for 6 months

[Glio]

he has been going out for some time. on x-men #11 he says that he is going to the cafe for 6 months

... Six months? If we start adding that to 8 months after Secret Wars the timeline collapses the more I think about it.

[ExodusCloak]

he has been going out for some time. on x-men #11 he says that he is going to the cafe for 6 months

So clearly Emma got him at one of those visits before. It's not the same scene from X-Men 11. Scott doesn't go "huh" there he goes ... and is dressed differently. And also shows that Scott wasn't under house arrest if he's going there months

[Omega Alpha]

Ah, okay. Well, wouldn't it have been more weird and messed up if he told kid Cable that he needed to see Jean and Emma? Did he honestly need to list everyone he cared about? Considering she was dead for so long and was finally back, it makes sense Jean would be the priority. I don't understand how this blew up.

Trolls blew it up. Scott doesn't mention Corsair or Alex, he just not care about them.

Yes, the Utopians joined him. Karma, Boom Boom and a lot of people that I do not remember or care about.

Yeah, although by the end Bendis seems to imply they will all be one team again, specially because arresting Scott after him pulling a MLK march would be political suicide.

[WhitePhoenix]

No Emma makes him go to the cafe. It's not a coincidence. What's shown in the comics is that he is not allowed to make a public appearance as Cyclops he is allowed to go to pubs as long as he's low key. He was also psychically coerced to be there. I'm pretty sure they'll reveal what and when in the later issues.

Unless that is printed in the comics as that’s what happened, that is all your headcanon. WiFi had him on lockdown, no way he magically was just able to walk out, when he’s being “cooped up”. Please stop being in denial.
8A639CB2-5BE7-4D97-89D5-6043E9DFCF3E.jpg
As of right now, I’m giving you proof, you haven’t given me as such.

[Glio]

That your son has you locked up and that he organizes an attack by a supervillain to an innocent family to take a test is something that I think we have not assimilated enough.

[ExodusCloak]

Unless that is printed in the comics as that’s what happened, that is all your headcanon. WiFi had him on lockdown, no way he magically was just able to walk out, when he’s being “cooped up”. Please stop being in denial.
8A639CB2-5BE7-4D97-89D5-6043E9DFCF3E.jpg
As of right now, I’m giving you proof, you haven’t given me as such.

My proof is that Scott has been going to that bar six months. And UXM 11 is not the same scene as his conversation with Emma.

And that if Emma wanted to meet him.without Scott or Cable.knowing shed brainwash them both into meeting in secret and not remembering

[Omega Alpha]

Rosenberg's wrong if he said 6 months- in X-force, only a few weeks passed. And none of the other MU books had a jump like that.

[Hizashi]

This nonsense about Scott not tripping over himself to run to Emma is kinda silly. She cares about him still, I'm happy about that - I want him to reciprocate the feelings, even if they don't get back together.

This issue was okay. The best parts were all the good Scemma moments~

General Whats-his-name is such a bad villain, I don't care about him at all. How can he let Emma and Scott run around like he does? He's too incompetent.

[AJpyro]

The fact Scott didn't tan Wifi's hide over that is a huge problem for me.