Originally Posted by
HeavenlyDemonic
It’s not surprising that editorial didn’t correct Jenkins’ continuity mistake. The reason that PAD left the Heroes Reborn era was because disagreements with editorial over the direction of Hulk’s character. So once he was, editorial completely ignored elements of his run for years, even after Jenkins’ run.
I’ve always hated the Professor retcon because it robs more 5 years worth of storylines of their intended emotional hook. Perhaps a better solution would have been to say that the merged hulk did exist as PAD originally planned up until the events of issue 425, where Betty is shot and Bruce has his mental breakdown. Then, due to the breakdown, just say he didn’t have the fortitude to maintain the merger anymore, so his subconscious created the Professor as a solution, and that’s the person that we see from the end of issue 426 until the end of the Onslaught event. It’s not a perfect answer, but it’s better than invalidating that whole section of the run character wise.