https://geekdad.com/2019/08/review-b...cupied-gotham/
Reading that review, they don't really contradict each other. Corrina just brought out some points that Ray didn't bring up. Ray speaks about what happened in the book and why it's compelling, while Corrina asks how these things happened in the first place, where's the logic and logistics of it, why some characters aren't there, and that's why she doesn't like it.