There are two aspects of this arc that I keep thinking back too in terms of whether I thought it was good or not. The first is how Horikoshi handled his absolutely immense cast of supporting characters. The second is the pacing of the entire arc. So let's focus on these two first.
Horikoshi does a stellar job in giving so many of the supporting cast hype moments throughout the arc. Whether it's stuff that have been building up throughout the series or giving more focus to characters that have lacked it. I think that in most cases Horikoshi nailed giving the supporting some time to shine. You got long-awaited moments like the Todoroki family settling their tragic drama and Ochako reaching her zenith as a heroine while reaching out to Toga's heart living up to the hype. Gentle and Nagant coming back to help out had me unreasonably excited. Supporting casts members like Jiro, Tokoyami, Shoji, Monoma, Shinso and many more getting to play important roles constantly brought a smile to my face.
But there's also a negative to this. First in that there are a few characters I think deserved a bit more. Iida got some time to shine, but it was mainly in helping Shoto get somewhere fast enough and helping Deku get back up on his feet. While that is fitting for his character, I wish he would've gotten something with more narrative meat to it. Sun-Eater and Nejire were unfortunately quite ineffective against Shigaraki. Stain's sacrifice felt quite rushed, inefficient and narratively unsatisfying. So not these hype moments weren't all equal. Making some of them stand out for the wrong reasons.
But the main problem is that I think there were so many that they cut too much into Deku's confrontation with Shigaraki. There was quite a long stretch where it seemed like they were just staring into each other while stuff got destroyed around them. When it would've been nice to have some more fight conversation and more coreographed fighting leading to the confrontation we got. And just to be clear I did like pretty much everything about Deku and Shiggy's fight. I just wish there would've been more of an escalation to it. It just felt like they were going 100% straight from start partly because there wasn't time for anything else, since so much focus was put on everybody else.
Which leads to the pacing. A lot of the individual segments are paced really well I think. Together they do form an arc that is maybe a bit too long for its own good. But that also gives it the appropritate grand scale for the series final battles. Mainly though it's AFO refusing to go down that feels the most drawn out, especially a certain times when you just want to go back to Deku and Shigaraki since that is the main rivalry of this arc. But it keeps going back to AFO fighting everybody else. Again, a lot of that fighting against AFO is really good stuff on its own. But man does it take a long time to bring him down. A bit too long really.
So those are the main two things. But I also have to mention how much I love most of the villains and the resolutions to their stories. They're all dangerous as all hell and need to go down because while they have legit gripes with the world, them killing and destroying things to get their way isn't an option. But despite that there's pretty much nothing triumphant about any of their defeats. There's no cheering (in-universe) when Dabi, Toga, Spinner and Shigaraki are brought down. Just a profound sadness that they all could've been saved in better times. But here they were just too filled with rage and hate to ever consider giving up (except for Toga who let love lead her possibly final act). But in the end they all held on to their convictions, and the writing never betrayed their personalities. Which I really liked.
Some other things:
- The initial setup for how the fights are all spread out is great.
- The reveal that AFO controlled so much of Shigaraki's life is by far the worst part of this arc. Could've been dropped without changing much of the story really.
- Bakugo getting "killed" and sutured didn't really do anything for me. Him fighting the last ember of AFO was surprisingly engaging. His final bit in the final battle was unnecessary.
Overall, while I do have some gripes with this arc, I think that the good to great stuff outweighs the bad. It's a bit long, but holy hell does it fit in a ton of awesome moments into its length.
|