Originally Posted by
Mr MajestiK
My reputation for speaking bluntly for many years in the countless Black Panther Appreciation threads, is well known so what I'm about to say, should come as no suprise to any of my fellow posters.
It's been acknowledged by my peers posting herein, that I was literally the only poster who rejected Ta Nehisi Coates from day one, before the first issue of his Black Panther solo ever saw the light of day.
You're all fully in the know as to how much I despise Coates distortions masquerading as contributions to the BP Mythos, so there's really no need for me to rehash any of said reasons within this post.
All I am going to make very clear in the next few paragraphs, is the following.
If you're in the habit of praising every aspect of Ta Henisi Coates wilfully deliberate alterations to the BP Mythos whilst ignoring the excellence that preceded Coates writing tenure on T'Challa's solo book, you are most definitely not a Black Panther enthusiast.
If you overlook the verifiable fact that post Maberry's Doomwar and the disgraceful AvX storyline, Ta Nehisi Coates is the single writer, most responsible for the sustained diminishing of T'Challa as a character and Wakanda as an intellectual concept, firmly rooted in an aggressive rejection of established stereotypes, you cannot in good conscience, describe yourself as a reader genuinely interested in T'Challa or the unique fictional world that serves as his intimate backdrop.
If you're more invested in supporting characters such as Storm and Eden and the feats Ta Nehisi Coates gives them, (which are yet to be acknowledged in their own family of mutant-centric books,)whilst continuously pushing T'Challa to the back of the bus with an increasingly heavy burden of irrelevancy weighing him down within what's ostensibly supposed to be his own SOLO book, you are without a shadow of a doubt, most definitely not a Black Panther enthusiast by even the most wildly believable stretches of the imagination.
So for those of you who love to celebrate the very deliberate distortions Ta Nehisi Coates has foisted upon the formerly boundary pushing Afrofuturistic vision the legendary duo, Stan Lee and Jack Kirby envisioned decades ago, ably followed by such literary giants as Don McGregor, Chrisopher J Priest, Dwayne McDuffie, Reginald Hudlin an David Liss, keep doing what you do, in the full knowledge that I will always be numbered amongst actual Black Panther enthusiasts, pushing back against the tide of disingenuousity that breaks upon the shores of the Black Panther Appreciation thread with ever increasing frequency.
No true BP enthusiast appreciative of genuine depictions of progressive, forward thinking explorations of speculative fiction, based within the realms of Afrofuturism or even high fantasy, would deign to celebrate Ta Nehisi Coates slave mentality inflected agenda, let alone his thoroughly a$$ backwards mission to force his own highly selective take on "reality" within a fantasy setting whilst simultaneously pushing the high fantasy elevation of his favoured character to "godhood" status, within a book that bears the title Black Panther boldly emblazoned upon its front cover month in, month out.
Peace.