What book's cancellation hit you the hardest?

[K7P5V]

Alan Davis's removal from Excalibur took all the charm from the book.

OMG! Totally agree. Truly the end of an era (IMHO):

[Dizzystarr]

What If....? I loved that series and was so sad when it ended in the late 90s now all we get is one shots every now and then it needs to be brought back as an ongoing thought for sure it would happen when Disney+ started airing the tv series but sadly no

[Hakka84]

What If....? I loved that series and was so sad when it ended in the late 90s now all we get is one shots every now and then it needs to be brought back as an ongoing thought for sure it would happen when Disney+ started airing the tv series but sadly no

Seconding this. They should resume the title, but What Ifs in which the characters aren't over-the-top or OOC. Usually, in the original What If, they brought the plots and characterizations to extreme. Which was fun and entertaining at times, but absurd in another (comes to my mind the What If that came out when Jean and Scott married - in which the "What If Jean dated Warren" lead to Scott turning to the Brotherhood. Like, what?).

[K7P5V]

For me, these would be My Top (3) Three choices...

• Young Allies

• New Mutants '03

• Agent X

[K7P5V]

The majority might not agree, but these three would be my next choices...

• X-Men: Evolution

• Sentinel

• The Pulse

[Mutant X]

S.W.O.R.D and Gillen's Uncanny X-men run.

Both were high-quality stories that were cut.

[K7P5V]

X-Men: Hidden Years.
As far as I can recall, it wasn't cancelled because it was a selling failure, but because of a relaunch of the X-Corner.

OMG! Totally agree. Truly a sad loss.

[Triniking1234]

Spider-Man/Deadpool.

I know they dropped that book cuz they got bored of sharing.

Also Uncanny Avengers vol. 3

[Dementia5]

Generation X, vol. 1
The all-female X-Men team (“XX-Men”)

[MichaelC]

Mutant X and Generation X

[Itchpfork]

Generation X volume 2. That one was a criminally underrated point of light in the X-Men's darkest decade.

[DarkMagnus]

Carey´s X-men Roguacy.

The definitive Rogue run.

Uncanny Vengers vol 3. that was so a good tenure of Rogue as a Avenger

[Soulsword323]

All New X-Factor.

[Dante Milton]

Williams' X-Factor, had such potential, I will forever be bitter that we didn't get more of the stories teased in that redacted resurrection data page.

Gen X vol.2, this book was so queer, I loved it. Bummed that we never got the Monet/Quentin mentorship that Strain talked about.

Spurrier's X-Force. One of the few iterations of X-Force that I really enjoyed, it just needed better art. Si did manage to give it a very satisfying ending though.

I would have loved for SWORD to continue alongside X-Men Red. I miss Taki.

Hellions. Would have liked to see them continue the concept with some new cast members.

I really liked All New X-Factor at the time, but I can't in good conscience really support PAD's work anymore.

[Nicoclaws]

Williams' X-Factor, had such potential, I will forever be bitter that we didn't get more of the stories teased in that redacted resurrection data page.

Gen X vol.2, this book was so queer, I loved it. Bummed that we never got the Monet/Quentin mentorship that Strain talked about.

Spurrier's X-Force. One of the few iterations of X-Force that I really enjoyed, it just needed better art. Si did manage to give it a very satisfying ending though.

I would have loved for SWORD to continue alongside X-Men Red. I miss Taki.

Hellions. Would have liked to see them continue the concept with some new cast members.

I really liked All New X-Factor at the time, but I can't in good conscience really support PAD's work anymore.

ooooh i didn't know that about Monet/Quentin relationship that would have been actually interesting.

What did PAD do I forgot ?